s starring Mickey and Judy.
Final Thoughts:
A little tougher, a little snappier, Babes on Broadway moves Mickey and Judy into young adult territory, falling in love and fighting over personal ethics as they make their way to the top of Broadway. During the elaborate production numbers, director Busby Berkeley again mesmerizes with his restless, searching camera.
GIRL CRAZY

Wealthy New York playboy Danny Churchill, Jr. (Mickey Rooney) has caused one too many embarrassing headlines for his publisher father (Henry O’Neill), so much so that Mr. Churchill has decided to send Junior way out west to the Cody College of Mines and Agriculture – where women don’t attend. On arrival at the dusty desert college, Danny spots Ginger Gray (Judy Garland), the granddaughter of Dean Phineas Armour (Guy Kibbee). Her car has broken down and Danny, immediately on the make, tries to fix the car while trying to make a date with the unresponsive Ginger. Once on campus, Danny’s smart-alecky ways don’t mesh with the fun-loving, natural cowboys who attend Cody, causing Danny to quit the school. But Ginger’s scorn for his quitting hits home, and he decides to stay.
Hoping to impress her, he offers to help when he finds out that the school is going to be closed down by the state due to low enrollment. Proposing a rodeo and beauty contest – in which he will crown the winner – Cody suddenly realizes that he’s in big trouble. Ginger obviously deserves the award, but the governor’s daughter, who can prove influential in keeping the school open, also thinks Danny will crown her the winner. But when Ginger spots Danny’s locket around the beauty’s neck, she’s had enough of Danny’s lies. Will Danny save the school, as well as his relationship with Ginger?
The best film in this collection, Girl Crazy sports a new director for the series (Berkeley was replaced with studio journeyman Norman Taurog after the I Got Rhythm number was shot), as well as a new location – the far west, and the musical genius of Ira and George Gershwin. War clouds are nowhere to be seen on the Girl Crazy horizon; this is pure musical romantic comedy terrain, and the speedy, sprightly set-ups keep the laughs and songs coming at a rapid clip. Girl Crazy opens like gangbusters with the fantastic knock-about Treat Me Rough, where a sexy-as-hell June Alyson makes like Betty Hutton, leading the chorus girls to push Mickey around like a rag doll.
Changing location but maintaining the comedic tone, Mickey moves west and starts to spar with Judy, and the duo finally reach a mature, adult, funny, and surprisingly romantic chemistry, bantering with an engaging give-and-take to their scenes that make you wish they had starred together in more films after achieving this welcome chemistry (their fun, sexy Could You Use Me? is nicely naughty). Mickey as always is a ball of fire, and nicely goonish in his inept wooing of Garland (showing shades of his young punk from Boys Town), while Judy shows the kind of vulnerable, romantic fragility, in her later scenes with Mickey, that remind you of the heights she’d achieve in films like A Star is Born and I Could Go On Singing. There’s an amazing scene where Mickey is trying to apologize and win Judy back, with Mickey nuzzling her neck while conflicting emotions continually sweep across her face. It’s a tour de force moment, and Garland is simply luminous.
The musical numbers, most of them staged by expected director Chuck Walters (he dances with Judy in the Embraceable You sequence), are quite nicely staged; Walter’s grasp of Judy’s strengths (making unfailing the audience gets to consult with her acting and living the lines) are evident, particularly in the delightful Embraceable You romp. Most greeting, too, is Tommy Dorsey and His Orchestra, knocking outdoors one of the tightest sets you’ll ever see on Gershwin’s Fascinating Rhythm (I love how Taurog creates an almost epic feel to the absolutely staged number, by slowly, slowly tracking that camera around the band). Berkeley’s sole contribution to Girl Crazy – the I Got Rhythm sequence – is another stunning set bawling-out from his career, with the strange, compelling introduction of rows of cowgirls and cowboys employing whips and pistols in mechanical exactitude, elevating the sequence onto a quite surreal aircraft (evidently, the studio didn’t like his slow, expensive handling of this scene, and canned him). There’s a giddy, barely overripe quality to this final hoe down, and it leaves the viewer pleasantly surprised at the abundance of ingenuity that wraps up the film: like any excellent, each chain tops the whilom one.

The DVD:
The Video:
Unfortunately, there’s quite a bit of heavy grain in the black and white, full screen 1.33:1 video image of Girl Crazy, which is especially noticeable in the luminous close-ups of Garland. Otherwise, a pretty good transfer.
The Audio:
Like all the other films in this collection, the audio is a Dolby Digital English mono mix, which accurately recreates the original theatrical presentation. Subtitles and close-captions are available.
The Extras:
Extras for Girl Crazy include another terrific commentary track by John Fricke; Hollywood Daredevils, a vintage short; The Early Bird Dood It, a vintage cartoon; a stereo remix for the I Got Rhythm sequence, and a theatrical trailer. An audio-only bonus includes an outtake for the deleted scene, Bronco Busters.
Final Thoughts:
Probably Judy and Mickey’s best film together, Girl Crazy moves quickly from one marvelous song to the next, providing plenty of laughs and charm along the way. George and Ira Gershwin finds perfect interpreters of their music in Rooney, Garland and Tommy Dorsey. A pristine example of producer Arthur Freed’s advanced musical technique, with a knock-out special assist from temporary director, Busby Berkeley.
Final Thoughts on the Box Set:
If the Mickey Rooney and Judy Garland Collection: Ultimate Collector’s Edition came with just the films and no extras, it would rate a highly recommended, just because the films are so important in the American film history timeline: they started, however small at first, the trend for Hollywood to increasingly cater to the youth market. They also happen to be marvelously entertaining, carefree musicals with two of the screen’s most consummate performers. But the Mickey Rooney and Judy Garland Collection: Ultimate Collector’s Edition contains a wealth of extras, including Private Screenings with Mickey Rooney, a TCM interview special; The Judy Garland Songbook, which includes 22 musical numbers from16 of her films; and , with trailers from ten of their films together. As well, there is the fifty-page hardcover Bonus DVD Guide, written by John Fricke, and the Mickey Rooney and Judy Garland Portfolio, a sleeve containing 20 high quality black and white stills on heavy 5 x 7 postercard stock, all packaged in a heavy silver foil cardboard slipcase. This is wonderfully excessive packaging that collectors dream about for their favorite stars and films, and Warner Bros. is to be commended. Therefore, considering the highest quality of the films themselves, in addition to the marvelous extras and packaging, I’m giving the Mickey Rooney and Judy Garland Collection: Ultimate Collector’s Edition our highest rating here at DVDTalk: the DVD Talk Collector Series rating.
Paul Mavis is an internationally published film and television historian, a member of the Online Film Critics Society, and the litterateur of The Espionage Filmography.


Agree? Disagree? You can post your thoughts about this review on the DVD Talk forums.
 |
| Other Reviews:
|
 |